Recently I attended a networking event and the seemingly endless debate for terms Latino VS Hispanic started.
Someone ended the discussion with the following statement.
"Really I could not possibly care less about what people or the government call me. Call me Latino. Call me Hispanic. Heck! Call me Beaner if you want."
Some people started laughing openly while some just giggled and some others waited to see what response would be most appropriate.
How politically incorrect is the term?
Does it depend on the intention?
Or is it just meaningful in certain circumstances?
Good topic. I really never put that much thought into the term Beaner. I tell you, it has been a while since I have heard it used. I guess it would depend on how a person receives the term and how it is used. For example, if a famous comedian, let's say George Lopez uses it, we would probably laugh. But, if it is used as an insult then those whom receive could react in a whole different way.
Politically incorrect? Are we really still using this type of thinking? How about we replace it with, "Treat others the way you want to be treated."
When I first heard the term I found it quite funny. After all I'm Mexican and the typical Mexican diet consists of tortillas and beans!
Most people easily give away control of their response by putting the negative emotional load on words themselves. A better way of thinking could be doing what comedian Carlos Mencia does.. just laugh it off!
Personally, I think it was degrading for this person to allow anyone to call him "beaner." Any time we say it is OK to do something unto ourselves, whether it be calling us names, or touching us in any way, we degrade ourselves, and our ethnicity. No -- beaner is not a good label to put on yourself. This person might as well have been a "been-er." He's been there and back and wants to continue in the same place.
It's demeaning and does not correspond to today's society. I literally take offense at anybody calling me by that term. We all need to treat and demand to be treated with respect.
Thanks for your post Rogelio. I've told some of my friends about this term and opinions are incredibly divided. Half of them concur with you and some others just say it all depends on the tone and intention.
Beaner is just a word even if meant offensively. like my mom always said "if the shoe fits.." if you take that word to be offensive then you will be offended. As for me, I could care less, as long as I know where I stand and am comfortable with who I am, beaner is just a word.
I also agree that what we give attention does indeed manifest. We as the adult Latino/Hispanic population she be uniting every minute of the day. Forget what they say about us today, because tomorrow is another day and most will be forgotten. Let us all strive for a better future making the path not only for ourselves but for our children.
Let us achieve together and today where many have failed. Remember achievement is the result of always trying your hardest and NEVER giving up.
Over a year ago, I met a person here in Hawaii, when we first moved here. The gentleman was a Latino from Mexico, him and his mother had moved to Hawaii, and had work visa's, he was attending the University, he made mention he had gotten a dog and had named it "Bean-er".
I told him how offensive that was, to Mexicans, here in the United States. I worker for a former company in Colorado where I was one of many who promoted Diversity Development, I told him it was wrong to exploit the Latino community by condoning a racist word. He told me that it was funny, and none of his other friend's found it offensive, his other friends I met later were all white,they thought it was funny as well,
Being really upset about the naming of a dog "Bean-er" showed little respect for his culture, one a dog, two a racial slur, and three lack of respect for others who grew up with these names as apart of our lives and the struggle we as a culture had experience in the 60's and still now sometimes!
I can remember seeing a sign as a young man in a restaurant window "No Mexicans or Dogs allowed" in Southern Colorado, mid sixty's.
He would not change the name, I told him I could not be friends with anyone who would allow himself to use such a word full of hate and disgust.
He said I was the one with the hangup, and for being born here I walk around with a chip on my shoulder, that I was guilty for not being a strong Latino who could not see it as just a word. That by doing this he was more excepting in mainstream America and that is why we (Latinos in America) have it so hard, because we find to many thing offensive, he said that is why we as a culture will never evolve as driving force in the United States we will always be 2nd class citizens, like our elders. Its our time to make the change to mainstream.
For a college guy what a crock of Poo! He's the type of person I grew up knowing as a sell out, Brown on the outside white on the inside. I'm a proud Mexican and American I know with my college education I still haven't sold out to be a part of the mainstream. By condoning this what are we telling our children, its okay to make fun of your culture to fit in, that's called being a token!
Its not just a word, its just as bad as the "N" word or the "F" word or any other word used to discount a race or a culture, shame on people for condoning the use of this words.
With 10,000+ members, the National Society for Hispanic Professionals is the top US networking association for Hispanic professionals. It's free to join and this is a great place for you to connect with new people who share your interests, BUT it's not for selling or promoting your business. Join us today and ask here if in doubt about our policy.